After some 3,500 comments, I asked Gemini to review a text file containing all those comments and spit out a review. The review is beneath the video, which, incidentally is very well made, easy to follow, and in my view an excellent no-messing about lesson on how to do project development, especially on a product which has been in the public domain for decades.
Overall Sentiment
The comments reflect a strong dichotomy: widespread criticism of the new logo and branding, but overwhelming praise for the planned software improvements, the video's transparency, and the development team's approach. Most commenters are excited about the future of the software itself, even if they dislike its new visual identity.
---
1. Intense Feedback on the New Logo and Rebranding
current branding
The most discussed topic by a significant margin is the rebranding, with most of the feedback being critical.
new suggestion in the video
* Loss of the Waveform: A vast number of users feel the waveform was the most iconic and essential part of the original logo, even more so than the headphones. Many believe its removal strips the logo of its identity and fails to communicate what the program does. Suggestions were frequently made to reincorporate a simplified waveform.
* Color Change: The shift from blue to red was jarring for many commenters, who strongly associate the color blue with Audacity's brand identity. They argue that the new red color feels alien and corporate.
* Aesthetic and Design: The new logo is frequently described as "lifeless," "sterile," "corporate," and "soulless". Some find the asymmetrical design to be visually unbalanced, awkward, and uncomfortable to look at. Others feel it looks like a generic stock icon that lacks personality.
* Loss of Recognisability: Many feel the new logo is so different that it's unrecognisable as Audacity, abandoning the charm and identity of the original. Several commenters compared it to other controversial corporate rebrands.
* Contextual Understanding: A smaller group of commenters noted that while the logo is strange on its own, it makes more sense and fits in well when viewed alongside the other apps in the Muse suite. Some simply expressed that they like the new modern look.
---
2. High Praise for the Video and the Presenter's Approach
There is near-universal acclaim for the video itself and the way the project is being managed and communicated.
* Transparency and Honesty: Commenters repeatedly praised the video's transparency, depth, and honesty about the development process, including the challenges of technical debt. Many wish other software projects, especially open-source ones, had this level of communication.
* Excellent Communication: The presenter is described as an inspiring and skilled leader who is excellent at communicating complex design principles and the reasoning behind decisions.
* Addressing Criticism: Viewers appreciated the direct response to poorly-researched, negative videos that criticized an early, unfinished build of the software.
---
3. Excitement and Support for Audacity 4.0's New Features
The actual changes to the software detailed in the video were met with widespread excitement and approval.
* UI/UX Improvements: Users are very enthusiastic about the modernized UI and thoughtful UX improvements. Many expressed that the video addressed long-standing frustrations they've had with the software for years.
* Specific Features: There was particular excitement for the introduction of non-destructive effects, the new "Split" tool, and the plan to eliminate confusing "modes". The solution of asking the user to choose their preferred delete behavior was lauded as a brilliant UX decision.
* Technical Decisions: The development team was commended for choosing to refactor the existing codebase rather than starting over and for migrating to Qt instead of a web-based framework like Electron.
---
4. Diverse and Creative Use Cases Mentioned by Users
The comments revealed the vast and sometimes unexpected ways people use Audacity.
* Standard Uses: Common uses mentioned include recording voice-overs, simple audio editing, cleaning up recordings, academic analysis, and as a first step into music production.
* Unconventional Uses: Several users mentioned creative and unusual applications, such as datamoshing and glitch art by importing raw image data (.bmp, .jpeg) as audio, applying effects, and exporting it back as an image.
* Niche Applications: Other uses include a lawyer using it to prepare audio evidence for court, creating maps for a rhythm game, and playing ARGs.
---
Audacity: Link
No comments:
Post a Comment